Mapping an Argument Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 words

Mapping an Argument - Essay ExampleThe courts role must remain to ensure congruous interpretation of the laws as opposed to participating in the political ideas and thus contributing to the political decisions of the people.The article raises various issues that are very fundamental in understanding the relationship between law and politics. The first major issue is the racial divide that was very prevalent in the Niagara Falls between the African Americans and the White Americans. The issue threatened politics of the council, as it appeared that the White majority voted as a bloc, based on race, to eliminate the African American preferable candidate (Curtin, 2002). When the matter was taken to the federal court, the judge found no evidence that the White majority had voted as a block on racial grounds. This decision however appeared to be more of a political decision than one based on law.Another important point expressed by the author is that the judiciary should refrain from the legislative process of the council, except in situations where such legislation process fronts to infringe on the rights of individuals to vote. The judiciary should have no other role in the political process of enacting laws apart from that of protecting peoples rights. In the case of the council of Niagara Falls, the legislative process did not seem to violate the one person-one vote principle and the judge therefore had no business involving himself in resolving it. The judges decision seemed to be meddling with a political process.Every society has its own culture and traditions that are different and unique from those of other societies. These cultures and traditions affect to a greater extent the worldviews of the individuals and how they deal out themselves in different situations. Cultural relativism demands that we do not judge other peoples cultures and traditions based on our own cultures. No culture is specially